A Case Study: The ROI of an Energy Audit for a Malaysian Shopping Mall

 https://www.techikara.com/

A Case Study: The ROI of an Energy Audit for a Malaysian Shopping Mall

Reading Time: Approximately 7-8 minutes

Key Takeaway: Are your electricity bills for your Malaysian shopping mall eating up a huge chunk of your profits? With air conditioning, lighting, and escalators running all day, every day, the energy costs for malls are enormous. Now, with the Energy Efficiency and Conservation Act (EECA) 2024 in full effect, large commercial buildings like malls are under new pressure to manage their energy better. You know you need to cut costs and improve efficiency, but will an energy audit actually pay for itself? This article presents A Case Study: The ROI of an Energy Audit for a Malaysian Shopping Mall, revealing how a professional energy audit isn't just a cost, but a smart investment with significant returns.

---

Problem: Operating a large Malaysian shopping mall means facing sky-high and often unpredictable energy bills, primarily from HVAC and lighting systems. Despite general awareness of energy waste, you lack precise data and a clear roadmap for substantial, sustained savings, leading to continued profit erosion and the looming challenge of complying with the EECA 2024's new mandates for large commercial buildings.

Agitate: Without a targeted energy audit, you're essentially pouring money down the drain on inefficient operations. This not only impacts your bottom line but also puts you at risk of non-compliance with new regulations, potentially leading to fines and a damaged reputation. The longer you wait, the more valuable savings opportunities you miss, and the further behind you fall in the competitive, energy-conscious market.

Solve: This case study demonstrates A Case Study: The ROI of an Energy Audit for a Malaysian Shopping Mall, illustrating how a comprehensive energy audit provides the specific, data-driven insights needed to identify significant savings. Discover how the investment in a professional audit can lead to substantial reductions in energy consumption, a rapid return on investment, and crucial support for meeting EECA 2024 requirements, turning your biggest operating cost into a powerful source of competitive advantage.

---

Summary

This Case Study: The ROI of an Energy Audit for a Malaysian Shopping Mall highlights the financial benefits of conducting a professional energy audit. Key takeaways:

• High Energy Consumers: Shopping malls are major energy users (mainly for AC and lighting), making them prime candidates for significant savings.
• Audit Provides Roadmap: An audit pinpoints specific areas of waste and recommends actionable solutions (Energy Conservation Measures, ECMs).
• Rapid ROI: Many energy efficiency projects identified through audits offer attractive Return on Investment (ROI) and short payback periods, proving the audit itself is a worthwhile investment.
• Compliance with EECA 2024: For large commercial buildings, EECA 2024 mandates energy management, including audits. The audit serves as a crucial step for compliance.
• Beyond Savings: Benefits extend to improved tenant comfort, extended equipment life, and a better environmental image.
• EACG 2.0: SEDA Malaysia's Energy Audit Conditional Grant (EACG 2.0) can help offset audit costs.

This case study shows that an energy audit for a shopping mall is not just an expense, but a strategic investment that pays dividends.

---

1. The Energy Challenge for Malaysian Shopping Malls

Picture a typical Malaysian shopping mall: bright lights, cool air conditioning blasting, escalators moving continuously, and countless electronic displays. All of this activity requires a huge amount of energy, mostly electricity. For mall owners and operators, energy bills are often the second-largest operating cost, right after staff salaries.

With rising electricity tariffs and the new Energy Efficiency and Conservation Act (EECA) 2024 now in effect (since January 1, 2025), Malaysian shopping malls are under more pressure than ever to manage their energy use efficiently. Under EECA 2024, if a commercial building has a Gross Floor Area (GFA) of 8,000 square meters (m2) or more, it will need to get a Building Energy Intensity (BEI) label from the Energy Commission. If this label shows the building's energy performance is below a certain standard, the mall will then be required to conduct an energy audit and put an energy management plan in place.

So, the question isn't if you should look at your energy use, but how to do it effectively to get real, measurable savings. That's where an energy audit comes in. But is it really worth the money? Let's look at A Case Study: The ROI of an Energy Audit for a Malaysian Shopping Mall to understand the benefits.

 

2. The Case Study: A Mid-Sized Malaysian Shopping Mall

For this case study, let's consider a hypothetical but realistic mid-sized shopping mall in a major city in Malaysia.

• Mall Size: Approximately 100,000 square meters (GFA)
• Primary Energy Users: Air conditioning (HVAC) systems, lighting (common areas, car parks, facade), escalators/elevators, common area power outlets, water pumps.
• Typical Energy Consumption: Shopping malls in Malaysia are very energy-intensive due to the need for constant cooling in a hot and humid climate. Air conditioning alone can account for 50-60% of total energy use, with lighting often making up another 20-30%.
• Challenge: The mall management noticed consistently high energy bills and was also aware of the upcoming EECA 2024 requirements, prompting them to seek professional help. They wanted to reduce operating costs and improve their environmental image.

The Action Taken: A Comprehensive Energy Audit

The mall decided to invest in a Level 2 Energy Audit (a detailed energy survey and analysis) conducted by a qualified Registered Energy Auditor (REA) from an Energy Service Company (ESCO). This audit was a crucial step in understanding their energy consumption patterns and identifying potential savings.

What the Energy Audit Involved:

• Data Collection: The REA team collected 12-24 months of electricity bills, floor plans, equipment specifications (for chillers, air handling units, pumps, lighting fixtures), and operational schedules.
• On-Site Inspection: The REA team spent several days at the mall, walking through all areas, observing equipment, noting operational practices, and identifying potential issues.
• Measurements and Monitoring: This was a key part. The team used specialized tools to measure:
• HVAC Performance: Temperatures, pressures, airflow rates, and power consumption of chillers, cooling towers, and air handling units (AHUs).
• Lighting Levels: Measured light levels in various areas to see if they were appropriate or if there was over-lighting.
• Motor Efficiency: Checked power consumption of pumps and fan motors.
• Occupancy Patterns: Observed foot traffic and operational hours.
• Interviews: They spoke with the mall's facility managers, maintenance staff, and security personnel to understand existing practices, problems, and historical data.
• Detailed Analysis: The collected data was then analyzed to create an energy breakdown, identify "Significant Energy Users" (SEUs), and calculate the Building Energy Index (BEI).
• Recommendations (Energy Conservation Measures - ECMs): The audit report outlined specific, actionable recommendations for energy savings, along with their estimated costs, projected annual savings, and payback periods.

 

3. Key Findings and Recommended Energy Conservation Measures (ECMs)

The energy audit for the Malaysian shopping mall revealed several key areas of significant energy waste. Here are some of the main findings and the recommended Energy Conservation Measures (ECMs):

1. HVAC System Optimization (Largest Savings Potential)

• Findings: The chillers were operating inefficiently due to older technology and improper set points. Air handling units (AHUs) were not optimized for varying occupancy levels, leading to over-cooling in some areas. There were also issues with fresh air intake not being controlled effectively, bringing in too much hot, humid air.
• Recommendations:
• Chiller Plant Optimization: Upgrade to high-efficiency chillers or implement a control system to optimize the existing chiller plant's operation based on actual cooling load. This might involve sequencing chillers more effectively and adjusting setpoints.
• AHU and VSD Installation: Install Variable Speed Drives (VSDs) on AHU and pump motors to match fan and pump speeds to actual demand, rather than running at full speed all the time.
• Demand Control Ventilation: Install CO2 sensors in high-traffic areas to control fresh air intake, reducing the load on the air conditioning system.
• Improved Temperature Setpoints: Adjust thermostat setpoints in common areas and for tenants (where possible) by a small degree (e.g., from 22°C to 24°C), which can lead to significant savings without compromising comfort.
• Estimated Annual Savings: 15-20% of total HVAC energy consumption.
• Estimated Payback Period: 2.5 - 4 years (depending on the extent of upgrades).

2. Lighting System Upgrades

• Findings: The mall still used a significant number of older, less efficient fluorescent lights and metal halide lamps in common areas, car parks, and the facade. Many areas were also over-lit for their function.
• Recommendations:
• LED Retrofit: Replace all fluorescent and metal halide lamps with energy-efficient LED lighting. LEDs consume significantly less electricity, last longer, and produce less heat (reducing AC load).
• Occupancy Sensors/Daylight Harvesting: Install occupancy sensors in low-traffic areas (e.g., storerooms, restrooms, some car park sections) and utilize daylight harvesting controls near skylights or large windows in common areas.
• Zoning and Scheduling: Implement better lighting zones and automatic scheduling to ensure lights are only on when and where needed.
• Estimated Annual Savings: 30-50% of total lighting energy consumption.
• Estimated Payback Period: 1.5 - 3 years (LEDs have a very good ROI).

3. Escalator and Elevator Optimization

• Findings: Escalators were running continuously even during low-traffic hours, consuming constant energy.
• Recommendations:
• Motion Sensors/Variable Speed Drives: Install motion sensors on escalators to activate them only when people approach, or implement VSDs to reduce speed during off-peak hours.
• Estimated Annual Savings: 10-15% of total escalator/elevator energy consumption.
• Estimated Payback Period: 3-5 years.

4. Power Factor Correction

• Findings: The mall had a low power factor, meaning they were being charged for "reactive power" by the utility company, leading to higher electricity bills.
• Recommendations:
• Install Power Factor Correction (PFC) Capacitors: This helps to improve the power factor, reducing penalties and improving overall electrical system efficiency.
• Estimated Annual Savings: 2-5% of overall electricity bill.
• Estimated Payback Period: Less than 1 year (often very quick ROI).

5. Behavioral Changes and Energy Management System (EnMS)

• Findings: While not directly equipment-related, there was a lack of a structured approach to energy management and limited staff awareness.
• Recommendations:
• Implement an EnMS: Establish an Energy Management System (EnMS) following principles like ISO 50001, led by a Registered Energy Manager (REM). This creates a systematic process for ongoing energy monitoring, target setting, and continuous improvement.
• Staff Training & Awareness: Conduct regular training sessions for mall staff and tenants on energy-saving practices.
• Regular Monitoring & Reporting: Implement continuous energy monitoring using smart meters and dashboards to track consumption and verify savings.
• Estimated Annual Savings: Difficult to quantify directly, but this foundation enables all other savings and ensures they are sustained.

 

4. The ROI (Return on Investment) of the Energy Audit

Let's look at the numbers for A Case Study: The ROI of an Energy Audit for a Malaysian Shopping Mall.

Initial Investment:

• Cost of the Energy Audit (Level 2): Let's estimate RM 50,000 - RM 80,000 for a detailed audit of a mall of this size, depending on complexity and auditor fees.
• (Note: The mall might have been eligible for SEDA Malaysia's Energy Audit Conditional Grant (EACG 2.0), which provides up to RM 100,000 to offset audit costs for eligible commercial buildings, significantly reducing their initial outlay).

Projected Energy Savings (based on audit recommendations):

• Total Energy Consumption (Baseline): Let's assume the mall's annual electricity bill was RM 5,000,000.
• Total Projected Savings from ECMs: The audit projected a potential for 18-25% overall energy reduction through a combination of the recommended ECMs.
• Annual Cost Savings: 20% of RM 5,000,000 = RM 1,000,000 per year.

Return on Investment (ROI) from the Audit Itself:

• Even without considering the grant, the audit's cost (say, RM 70,000) is recovered within less than one month from the projected annual energy savings of RM 1,000,000.
• This demonstrates that the audit itself is a very small investment compared to the massive, ongoing savings it unlocks.

Implementation of ECMs (Estimated Costs & Paybacks):

• Total Investment for ECMs: Depending on the scope, let's estimate RM 2,000,000 - RM 3,000,000 for major upgrades (chillers, VSDs, full LED retrofit).
• Overall Simple Payback Period for ECMs: With annual savings of RM 1,000,000, the total investment in ECMs would have a payback period of 2-3 years.

Beyond Financial ROI:

• EECA 2024 Compliance: The audit provided the necessary data and a clear plan to meet the requirements of the EECA 2024 for commercial buildings, avoiding potential fines.
• Enhanced Reputation: The mall could now market itself as an environmentally responsible and energy-efficient building, attracting more tenants and customers who value sustainability.
• Improved Comfort: Optimized HVAC systems can lead to more consistent temperatures and better indoor air quality for shoppers and tenants.
• Extended Equipment Life: Better maintenance and optimized operation, often identified through audits, can extend the life of expensive equipment, reducing capital expenditure in the long run.
• Reduced Maintenance Costs: LED lighting, for example, has a much longer lifespan than traditional bulbs, leading to fewer replacements and lower labor costs.

This case study clearly illustrates that A Case Study: The ROI of an Energy Audit for a Malaysian Shopping Mall is overwhelmingly positive. It's not an expense, but a strategic investment that pays for itself quickly and continues to generate savings for years to come.

In conclusion, this Case Study: The ROI of an Energy Audit for a Malaysian Shopping Mall unequivocally demonstrates that a professional energy audit is a highly profitable investment, not just an expense. For large commercial buildings like shopping malls in Malaysia, grappling with high energy consumption and the new mandates of the Energy Efficiency and Conservation Act (EECA) 2024, an energy audit provides the essential roadmap to unlock significant and sustainable cost savings. As seen in this example, the initial cost of the audit is typically recouped within a matter of weeks, while the identified Energy Conservation Measures (ECMs) offer rapid payback periods, often within 2-3 years. Beyond the impressive financial returns, an audit ensures crucial compliance with EECA 2024, enhances your mall's environmental reputation, improves occupant comfort, and extends equipment lifespan. Furthermore, government incentives like SEDA Malaysia's Energy Audit Conditional Grant (EACG 2.0) can further boost your Return on Investment.

Are your mall's energy bills still soaring, and are you prepared for EECA 2024 compliance? Don't miss out on substantial, recurring savings. Our expert team can connect you with qualified Registered Energy Auditors (REAs) and guide you through the energy audit process, helping you identify and implement cost-effective solutions tailored to your mall's specific needs. Let's turn your energy challenges into a powerful profit driver. WhatsApp or call us today at 0133006284 for a comprehensive consultation and begin your journey towards energy efficiency and increased profitability!